Why Does Project Management Fail?

“It must be remembered that project management is first and foremost a philosophy of management, not an elaborate set of tools and techniques. It will only be as effective as the people who use it.”
- Bryce’s Law

INTRODUCTION

I often run into companies who ask the simple question, “Why can’t we get our act together? Why does Project Management routinely fail in our company?” I do not believe a company’s overall problems in Project Management can be attributed to a specific tool or technique (although some certainly do not help matters). Instead, I believe it is based on how important a company considers Project Management to be. If they believe it to be a vital part of the company’s overall performance, it will be more successful than a company who considers it irrelevant. In other words, I view Project Management as integral part of the corporate culture.

Let’s consider the indicators of how a company values Project
Management:

• LACK OF KNOWLEDGE – employees simply lack the basic knowledge
  of the mechanics of Project Management. I do not run into too many companies anymore with a total absence of knowledge in this regard. The conceptual foundation of Project Management has been around for a number of years. There is a multitude of training programs in Project Management, both at the college and commercial level. There are also several discussion groups on the Internet and professional associations dealing with this subject (e.g., the Project Management Institute of Newtown Square, PA). Hiring or contracting people with absolutely no knowledge of basic Project Management concepts is becoming a rarity.

• LACK OF ORGANIZATIONAL POLICY – the company has not adopted a formal policy for managing projects. Consequently, informal and inconsistent approaches to project management are used with mixed results. This is a much more common occurrence than finding a company devoid of knowledge in Project Management.
• LACK OF ENFORCEMENT OF POLICY AND PROCEDURES – even though a policy has been established, it is not enforced. As a result, inconsistent results emerge. If a standard and consistent approach to Project Management is devised by a company, it must be routinely policed in order to assure accuracy and uniform results. It is one thing to enact legislation, quite another to enforce it.
• LACK OF CONSIDERATION FOR THE MAGNITUDE AND COMPLEXITIES OF PROJECT MANAGEMENT AND ATTACK IT IN PIECE MEAL – People seem to naturally underestimate the magnitude of project management. For example, project planning involves defining work breakdown structures and dependencies which is a precursor to estimating, planning, reporting and control; estimating is a prerequisite to scheduling; time reporting impacts project estimates and schedules; resource allocation is based on availability of qualified people (skills inventory) and current project schedules; etc. There is an overwhelming number of software packages on the market attacking various aspects of Project Management, but very few addressing it is an integrated whole.

It must be remembered that project management is first and foremost a philosophy of management, not an elaborate set of tools and techniques, nor is it an administrative function. Rather, it is concerned with managing human beings towards the accomplishment of work (it is a “people management” function). As such, project management will only be as effective as the
people who use it.

Ultimately, project management represents DISCIPLINE, ORGANIZATION, and ACCOUNTABILITY; which are three areas people seem to have a natural aversion to these days.

DISCIPLINE – In the western world, people tend to resist discipline because some believe it inhibits creativity and personal freedom. As a result, teamwork is often sacrificed in favor of rugged individualism.

ORGANIZATION – Pursuant to discipline is the problem of organization. Again, in the western world, people prefer to maintain their own identity and organize themselves to meet their needs as opposed to the needs of the organization. There are also those who claim, “A cluttered desk is the sign of a brilliant mind.” Hogwash. In contrast, I am a believer of the Navy’s regimen whereby you either work on something, file it, or throw it away. This forces people to get organized. If we need more files, let’s get them. A cluttered desk is a sign of a disorganized person. Shape up, or ship out.

ACCOUNTABILITY – This is an area people tend to rebel against the
most. The approach to project management, as advocated by “PRIDE,” ultimately represents visibility and responsibility to produce according to plan. Unfortunately, some people shun commitments and, instead, prefer to hide their activity, thereby they cannot be measured and evaluated. This is typically the reaction of people who are insecure. People who are confident in their abilities have no problem with the accountability issue.

REACTIVE VS. ACTIVE MANAGEMENT

The old adage, “If you do not make the decision, the decision will be made for you,” is valid. This also sums up the difference between an active and a reactive manager. True Project Management requires an “active” manager, not “reactive.” The active manager takes care of the problems before they happen. They plan on the future. The reactive manager deals with yesterday and waits until problems occur, then tries to take care of them. Today, more and more IT organizations find themselves in a constant “firefighting” mode of operation. Why? Because of a “reactive” management style. The “reactive” manager never seems to get ahead, yet probably enjoys the highest visibility in the company. As an aside, beware of your “firefighters,” they are probably your chief arsonists.

Managers don’t wait for things to happen, they make things happen.

HOW MUCH PROJECT MANAGEMENT IS NECESSARY?

Can the philosophies of project management be adopted and implemented by a single group of people for a single project? Yes. A department or division? Certainly. The entire company? Definitely. In fact, as the scope grows, communications improves and the philosophy is more consistently applied.

The scope of project management affects many people:

• The individual worker will prepare estimates and schedules,
  perform project work, and report on activities.

• The project manager will plan and direct the use of resources on projects, and solve problems.
• Department managers will administer resources and control projects within an area.
• Executive management will establish project priorities and monitor project progress.

Obviously, project management should not be restricted to a handful of people or projects. Dozens of projects may be active at any one time, involving hundreds of workers across departmental boundaries. Synchronization of the work effort is required to maximize effect and minimize confusion. Project
management, therefore, should be viewed as a corporate philosophy as opposed to a technique used by a select few. Only when a standard and consistent approach to Project Management is adopted by a company will it become an integral part of the corporate culture. We will then hear less about why Project Management fails, and more of how the company is prospering.

For additional information on “PRIDE” Project Management, see:
http://www.phmainstreet.com/mba/pride/pm.htm

About the Author

Tim Bryce is the Managing Director of M. Bryce & Associates (MBA) of Palm Harbor, Florida, a management consulting firm specializing in Information Resource Management (IRM). Mr. Bryce has over 30 years of experience in the field. He is available for training and consulting on an international basis. His corporate web page is at:

http://www.phmainstreet.com/mba/

He can be contacted at: timb001@phmainstreet.com

Copyright © 2006 MBA. All rights reserved.

Video project-tools, machines, techniques

Project 2003 Step by Step $21.95 This practical, hands on tutorial expertly builds your skills with Microsoft Project 2003—one step at a time! With STEP BY STEP, you work at your own pace through easy to follow lessons and practice exercises to learn exactly the tools and techniques you need. Discover how to develop a project plan with tasks, resources, and assignments; create reports; manage multiple projects and dependencies; and track progress and costs while making real time adjustments. Plus you’ll learn about improvements in team collaboration using SharePoint Team Services, Project Web Access, Project Server, and more. The book also makes a great on the job desk reference. Designed for beginner and intermediate level users, STEP BY STEP puts you in charge of developing the skills you need, exactly when you need them! Authors: Carl Chatfield & Timothy Johnson Published: October 2003 ISBN 0 7356 1955 7 560 Pages

Handbuilt Pottery Techniques Revealed Handbuilt Pottery Techniques Revealed $22.49 This book reveals the secrets of handbuilding shown in unique cutaway photography. Here are directions for many creative, fun-to-do pottery projects potters can follow to produce handsome finished objects without need of a potter?s wheel. The author instructs in coil, slab, mold, and pinch techniques to produce pots, bowls, vases, tiles, and other decorative pieces. She also advises on acquiring basic tools, mixing and preparing clay, and using coloring agents. Newcomers to pottery crafting will especially appreciate her tips for making projects easier to accomplish, such as use of a hairdryer at regular intervals for drying out too-wet clay, and easy methods for keeping clay soft and pliable. Step-by-step color photos with detailed captions guide handcrafters through each project from start to finish. Many photos are of the cutaway type to show correct hand positions for controlling the clay, both inside and outside the form. Here?s the book that takes the mystery out of handbuildingi

Pro Tools 101 Official Courseware, Version 9.0 $39.95 Pro Tools 101 Official Courseware takes a comprehensive approach to learning the fundamentals of Pro Tools. Now updated for Pro Tools 9, this new edition covers everything you need to know to complete a Pro Tools project. Learn to build sessions that include multitrack recordings of live instruments, MIDI sequences, software synthesizers, and virtual instruments. Through hands on tutorials, develop essential techniques for recording, editing, and mixing. The included DVD ROM offers tutorial files and videos, additional documentation, and Pro Tools sessions to accompany the projects in the text. Developed as the foundation course of the official Avid Pro Tools Certification program, the guide can be used to learn on your own or to pursue formal certification through an Avid Authorized Training Partner. Join the ranks of audio professionals around the world as you unleash the creative power of Pro Tools.

Guitar Techniques $12.95 “(Strumming, Picking, Bending, Vibrato, Tapping, and Other Essential Tools of the Trade). Guitar Method. Play Along. Softcover with CD. Guitar tablature. 64 pages. Published by Hal Leonard”

Adobe Premiere Pro 2.0 Studio Techniques $31.95 Ready to discover not just the how, but also the why behind some of the most powerful features in Premiere Pro? In Adobe Premiere Pro 2.0 Studio Techniques, author Jacob Rosenberg goes beyond conventional stepby step instruction to give you a real world perspective on editing with Premiere Pro. Using Jacob’s fi lm footage or your own, you’ll learn to deliver professional quality results. Whether you’re looking for advice on editing, effects, titles, or working with audio, this easy to read guide will help you add more punch to your productions. • New features in Premiere Pro 2.0: Native HD support, native HDV editing, 24P/24PA support, DVD authoring from the timeline, expedited reviewing with Adobe Clip Notes—it’s all here. Find out how Premiere Pro has been improved, what’s been added, and how to use new features. • Working fundamentals: From capturing video to assembling your project to the new, panel based user interface, get an under the hood understanding of this powerful application. • Advanced techniques: Through hands on lessons, learn the ins and outs of color correction, color matching, multiple camera editing, dynamic photomontages, titling, audio and video effects, sound mixing, professional workflows for feature films and HD productions, and more. • Companion DVD: You’ll fi nd extra chapters and bonus reference material to read, video tutorials to watch, media fi les to use with the book’s lessons, tryout versions of Adobe Premiere Pro 2.0 and Adobe Audition 2.0, and indispensable plug ins to install. Jacob Rosenberg is a Los Angeles–based independent filmmaker who has directed nationally broadcast commercials, music videos for such groups as the Baha Men, and several short films. Recently, Jacob has worked as a post production supervisor on a number of feature films that used high definition video as their digital intermediate format. A current member of the Adobe Premiere development team, and the featured instructor for Premiere Pro on the highly acclaimed Total Training Instructional DVD series, Jacob continues to raise the bar by creating new workflows and educating others about them. From IBC in Amsterdam to NAB in Las Vegas, Jacob teaches classes around the world on using Premiere Pro and other Adobe products. “With this book and Adobe Premiere Pro, you’ll have all the tools you need to create your own professional quality movies and videos. Jacob shows you how to think like a filmmaker, get the job done, and understand the creative process from start to finish.” —Steven Warner Director of Engineering, Adobe Systems Inc. “Jacob has tirelessly advanced the art of filmmaking with Premiere’s ever expanding functionality, and his book demonstrates the depth and breadth of his creative artistry and technical know how.” —Rob Legato Film director and Academy Award winning Visual Effects Supervisor for Titanic About the Author Los Angeles based filmmaker and Premiere expert Jacob Rosenberg has worked closely with Adobe’s softwar

---

Comments are closed